The packaging is gorgeous, as YSL usually is. What I don't love is the price ($32) and the pigmentation -- I hesitated originally to purchase this because I thought to myself "Do I really need another pinky-nude natural lip product"? Sephora was sold out, so I took it as a sign. But, when I was notified that the #3 shade was back in stock, I hopped on the bandwagon.
Before I purchased, I thought that the Volupté Tint-In-Oil might be similar to my favorite Loreal Colour Caresse Wet Shine Lip Stain. This is my go-to lip color in shade "Rose On and On". The YSL oil is much more moisturizing and soft, while the Loreal still has the slick feel but is slightly more tacky. But, the Loreal trumps YSL in pigment, and it still makes my lips look juicy.
|Left to Right: YSL Volupté Tint-In-Oil in Undress Me, Loreal Colour Caresse in Rose On And On, & Loreal Colour Caresse in Infinite Fuschia|